ECHO - Evolutionary Convergence in Historical Oceans: The case of whales and ichthyosaurs

Why do so many marine animals have a fish-shaped body? Is it for swimming faster, eating better or for reproduction? Are all fish-shaped animals doing the same things?

Comparison of extant toothed whales and extinct ichthyosaurs

Comparison of extant toothed whales (A-C) and extinct ichthyosaurs (D-F) with emphasis on feeding and their tongue bones (red colour). In C and F, the skull skeleton is seen from below. From Delsett et al. 2023.

About the project

Through the history of life, a streamlined body propelled by a strong tail has evolved in several animal groups. This phenomenon is called convergent evolution: Two or more organisms evolving similar adaptations in response to the same environment and lifestyle.

In most biology books on the topic, you will find two fish-shaped animals as the prime example: One reptile, the extinct ichthyosaur (“fish lizards”), and one mammal, the dolphin. Both of these had ancestors on land, and evolved into fully marine creatures in the wake of a mass extinction. The ichthyosaurs existed for 150 million years ago before they died out.

Like an echo of these oceanic top predators, whales evolved a fish-shape and a similar lifestyle millions of years after and share the oceans with humans today.

ECHO will enable us to answer questions about the important things in life: moving, eating and giving birth. Modern whales are excellent models for understanding how to live under water, and will help us understand ichthyosaurs, which we can never see in the wild. The ichthyosaurs, on the other hand, offer an evolutionary history three times as long as whales. They went through mass extinctions and climate change and might tell us how large, marine vertebrates cope with change.

Looking inside ichthyosaur fossils
Looking inside ichthyosaur fossils. Different ways to study inner microstructure of Triassic vertebrae.

Main goals

The overarching objective of ECHO is to determine to which extent, across different eras and levels of biological organization, the convergent evolution of streamlined marine tetrapods results from similar evolutionary pathways.

Bildet kan inneholde: himmel, sky, fjell, økoregion, vann.
Many ichthyosaur fossils that provide data for ECHO have been excavated at Spitsbergen in the Arctic since 2004

Hypotheses

  • Ichthyosaur viviparity facilitated invasion of pelagic ecosystems.
  • Ichthyosaurs and whales followed similar evolutionary pathways toward a common thunniform body shape, corroborated by microstructural signatures.
  • Ichthyosaurs and tooth whales use similar feeding mechanisms, corroborated by the inner microstructure and outer shape of the hyobranchial arch.

Methodology

In the research project ECHO, we will take a closer look at ichthyosaurs and whales, and their evolution. In order to answer whether they really were each other’s echo through deep time, we will study fossil ichthyosaurs, fossil whales and the whales that live today.

The data will be collected from the outside and inside of skeletons, which means we will be able to combine and compare information from several levels of biological organization.

Blue whale skull in the collections at the Smithsonian.
The project will use museum specimens of whales and ichthyosaurs. This is a blue whale skull in the collections at the Smithsonian.

Publikasjoner

  • Rojo, Maximo A.; Delsett, Lene L.; Ruciński, Maciej; Hoffeker, Endre T. A.; Lund, Bjørn & Bjerke, Bjørn Aksel [Vis alle 7 forfattere av denne artikkelen] (2026). Preparation and mounting of a sperm whale (Physeter macrocephalus Linnaeus, 1758) at the Natural History Museum in Oslo, Norway. Natural History Collections and Museomics (NHCM). 3. doi: 10.3897/nhcm.3.191751. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Expanding the osteohistological toolbox for palaeophysiological studies. Lethaia: An International Journal of Palaeontology and Stratigraphy. ISSN 0024-1164. 59(1), s. 1–14. doi: 10.18261/let.59.1.4. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe; Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure; Engelschiøn, Victoria Sjøholt; Alexandra, Houssaye,; Anusuya, Chinsamy, & Hurum, Jørn Harald [Vis alle 7 forfattere av denne artikkelen] (2025). Vertebral microstructure marks the emergence of pelagic ichthyosaurs soon after the End Permian Mass Extinction. Scientific Reports. 15. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-14335-y. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Kinzella, Zoe; Cotton, Laura & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). New plesiosaur fossils from the Pliensbachian (Early Jurassic) of Bornholm, including the first juvenile specimen from Denmark. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark. ISSN 0011-6297. 74, s. 197–208. doi: 10.37570/bgsd-2025-74-10. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Seon, Nicolas; Vincent, Peggy; Delsett, Lene Liebe; Poulallion, Eve; Suan, Guillaume & Lécuyer, Christophe [Vis alle 10 forfattere av denne artikkelen] (2025). Reassessment of body temperature and thermoregulation strategies in Mesozoic marine reptiles. Paleobiology. ISSN 0094-8373. 51(2), s. 323–343. doi: 10.1017/pab.2025.2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure (2024). Pseudosuchian thermometabolism: A review of the past two decades. The Anatomical Record: Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology. ISSN 1932-8486. doi: 10.1002/ar.25609. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure; Woodward, Holly N.; Aubier, Paul & Cubo, Jorge (2024). On the origins of endothermy in amniotes. iScience. 27(4). doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2024.109375. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe; Pyenson, Nicholas; Miedema, Feiko & Hammer, Øyvind (2023). Is the hyoid a constraint on innovation? A study in convergence driving feeding in fish-shaped marine tetrapods. Paleobiology. ISSN 0094-8373. 49(4), s. 684–699. doi: 10.1017/pab.2023.12. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv

Se alle arbeider i NVA

  • Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure; Doriath-Döhler, Aimie & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2026). Résultats thermométaboliques et physiologiques paradoxaux chez les ichtyosaures. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Martiniussen, Erik & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2026). #21 Lene Liebe Delsett om live…–Erik M – Apple Podcasts. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2026). Dinosaurer og andre dyr. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2026). Forskning på livet i dinosaurtiden. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Kjørstad, Elise & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2026). Beistet fra kritt-tiden kan være den største blekkspruten som er oppdaget. [Journal]. forskning.no. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Gramling, Carolyn & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). How an ancient marine predator snuck up on its prey. [Journal]. Science News. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Til vanns, til lands og tilbake til vann. Geonytt. ISSN 2703-8580. 30(1), s. 6–8. doi: https:/www.geologi.no/images/Geonytt/2025/Geonytt1_25_nett.pdf. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Buehler, Jake & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Ancient sea turtle discovered in Lebanon reveals a surprising evolutionary history. [Journal]. Science. doi: https:/www.science.org/content/article/ancient-sea-turtle-discovered-lebanon-reveals-surprising-evolutionary-history. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Loge, Julia & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). - Vi liker at folk liker dinosaurer. [Journal]. Forskerforum. doi: https:/www.forskerforum.no/pdf-visning/?pdf=118510. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Building a body for the open ocean. The classical case of whales and ichthyosaurs. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Mindre feilaktige bilder av hvaler. Virveldyr fra tørt land til åpent hav. doi: https:/bio.no/bio-konferansen-program. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Marine tetrapod evolution. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Leine, Jan Erlend & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Ekko 11.februar 2025. [Radio]. NRK P2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Jemterud, Torkild; Delsett, Lene Liebe; Sandtorv, Alexander Harald & Normann, Ben David (2025). Hvor kom energien til Big bang fra? - Abels tårn - NRK Radio. [Radio]. NRK P2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Jemterud, Torkild; Dietrichs, Erik Sveberg; Delsett, Lene Liebe; Bøckman, Petter; Gravensteen, Ida Kathrine & Storehaug, Ida Torkjellsdatter [Vis alle 7 forfattere av denne artikkelen] (2025). Blir du frisk raskere uten paracet? - Abels tårn - NRK Radio. [Radio]. NRK P2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Jemterud, Torkild; Delsett, Lene Liebe; Røyne, Anja & Hrubos-Strøm, Harald (2025). Hvorfor får du dårlig ånde av å sove? - Abels tårn - NRK Radio. [Radio]. NRKP2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Jemterud, Torkild; Delsett, Lene Liebe; Espe, Emil Knut Stenersen & Røislien, Jo (2025). Kan et lyn redde livet ditt? - Abels tårn - NRK Radio. [Radio]. NRKP2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Kjørstad, Elise & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Denne ur-anda levde på samme tid som Tyrannosaurus rex. [Journal]. forskning.no. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe & Aas, Vilde Aardahl (2025). For 100 millioner år siden herjet blekksprutene i havet. [Journal]. forskning.no. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Fiskeøgle-fostre fra Svalbard er med på å vise noe nytt om dyrenes­ utvikling. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe; Chinsamy, Anusuya; Kimball, Justin; Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure; Sukhavasi, Vandith & Alam, Parvez [Vis alle 10 forfattere av denne artikkelen] (2025). Swim like a fish: vertebral perspectives on the locomotory convergence of ichthyosaurs and whales. doi: https:/vertpaleo.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/2025_SVP_Program_Final_Final.pdf. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Entering the oceans: repeated evolution of large marine vertebrates. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2025). Petroleum and whale oil. How to not talk about marine vertebrates. doi: 10.5281/zenodo.16810950. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Anell, Ingrid; Jemterud, Torkild; Delsett, Lene Liebe & Joner, Erik (2025). Abels tårn - NRK Radio. [Radio]. nrk. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure (2024). What does a word mean? On the terminology of endothermy. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Kjørstad, Elise & Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure (2024). Var ur-forfedrene våre kaldblodige? [Internet]. forskning.no. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Ichthyosaurs' metabolism: First results. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). How to grow a fish-shaped tetrapod. Insights from modest bones and inner structures. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Er det andre arter enn mennesket som har trassige barn? [Internet]. titan.uio.no. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Korne, Haley De; Moen, Ole Martin; Drożdżowicz, Anna & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). #13 Tverrfaglighet - til glede eller besvær? [Radio]. Forskerrådet. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Jemterud, Torkild; Normann, Ben David; Swang, Ole & Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Abels tårn 18. november 2024. [Radio]. NRK P2. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Samlingenes Grand Prix: Hvordan skaper vi fascinasjon for samlingene. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Kunne menneskene levd i havet? Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Whales as museum collections objects: What do they tell? Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Gruvedrift på havbunnen: Derfor protesterer forskere uvanlig høylytt. Morgenbladet. ISSN 0805-3847. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Hva skal spekkhoggere med overgangsalder? Morgenbladet. ISSN 0805-3847. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). For lenge, lenge, lenge siden! Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Fiskeøglefossiler og delfinbabyer. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Paleontologi og evolusjon. [Radio]. Naturfagpodden. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe; Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure; Engelschiøn, Victoria Sjøholt; Houssaye, Alexandra; Chinsamy-Turan, Anusuya & Kear, Benjamin P. [Vis alle 7 forfattere av denne artikkelen] (2024). Growth patterns in the vertebral column of two Triassic ichthyosaurs. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe; Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure; Holm, Thomas Bang; Schneider, Simon & Engelschiøn, Victoria Sjøholt (2024). How to use a vertebral column. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2024). Har dinosaurknoklene blitt til stein? [Journal]. ung.forskning.no. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2023). Livet, universet og alt: Dinosaurer del 1 og 2. [Radio]. Radio revolt podcast: Livet, universet og alt. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2023). Fossil energy. Evolution of marine giants. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2023). ECHO. Evolutionary convergence in historical oceans - the case of whales and ichthyosaurs. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2023). Dolphins of the Mesozoic? Using Arctic ichthyosaurs to map the extent of convergent evolution to whales. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe & Brac, Mathieu Gabriel Faure (2023). ECHO. Evolutionary convergence in historical oceans - the case of whales and ichthyosaurs. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv
  • Delsett, Lene Liebe (2023). Større enn blåhvalen? Paleobloggen. Fulltekst i vitenarkiv

Se alle arbeider i NVA

Emneord: Convergent evolution, ichthyosaurs, whales
Publisert 4. juli 2023 15:31 - Sist endret 12. feb. 2026 15:29